Which convention is more common „static public function” or „public static function” (based on Symfony and Doctrine)
2010-01-25Few minutes ago Brent Shaffer asked on the Twitter
Which is more standard, „public static function” or „static public function”?
I was curious about it, so I’ve checked which convention is used in my favourite Symfony Project. Of course, I haven’t got enough time to check it manually, class by class, so I wrote simple bash script:
egrep "^[^\*/]*static.*function" /usr/share/php/symfony/ -rioh --include=*.php | sed 's/^\s*//g' | sort | uniq -c | sort -r
The answer for the Symfony 1.2 was:
685 public static function 181 static public function 27 static protected function 16 protected static function 16 private static function 11 static function 2 abstract public static function
I’ve done same thing for Doctrine ORM Project
egrep "^[^\*/]*static.*function" /usr/share/php/Doctrine/lib/ -rioh --include=*.php | sed 's/^\s*//g' | sort | uniq -c | sort -r
and the result was:
78 public static function 6 static public function 6 static protected function
Now I can tell that „public static function” is more common, and by the way I use same convention in my classes 🙂